readergirlz is a literacy and social media project for teens, awarded the National Book Foundation's Innovations in Reading Prize. The rgz blog serves as a depot for news and YA reviews from industry professionals and teens. As volunteers return full force to their own YA writing, the organization continues to hold one initiative a year to impact teen literacy. All are welcome to "like" us on Facebook!

Tuesday, February 7, 2012

Book Fight: Cancer Books Don't Suck

So, I had this book fight in my head. I just finished The Fault in Our Stars. It's beautiful 
and wonderful, and I, as always, give a standing ovation to John Green. His wit, 
philosophy, theology, and worldview are packed inside this work I will remember.

That said, my mind hung on protagonist Hazel Grace's statement that "cancer books 
suck." She goes on to explain the kind she means, and I totally get it. But wait, I thought. 
I wrote a book about cancer! It wasn't but a second later that I began to question my 
own work, and even worse, "Do I suck BECAUSE I wrote a book about cancer?" It 
doesn't take much, right? I know. Try living in my brain.

Anyway, I felt I had the right to speak back to Hazel as I sorted through my thoughts. 
Like her, I had thyroid cancer. I had thyroid removal and follow-up radioactive iodine 
treatment. I was radioactive in isolation for two weeks. I still have autoimmune diseases, 
one of which raises my chance of lymphoma 44 times more than others. Last week, 
doctors were checking for leukemia. Nope. But I am under watch regularly to verify I'm 
not lighting up the scans.

That said, I want to make the case that cancer books don't suck if they are honest. 
I loved the touchpoints between The Fault in Our Stars and my own work Loose Threads
There are themes, moments, and choices that echo between them because of common experience. But then there are divergent thoughts around the why and what for. 
Worldviews that split from each other; truths we wouldn't agree upon but are so
 thought-provoking and challenging, regardless.

Eventually, I did realize: Wait! Hazel loves a cancer book. The Fault in Our Stars is a
cancer book. John wrote a cancer book. He doesn't suck. Loose Threads is equally 
honest and doesn't suck either. And neither do I. Well, for the moment. In this realm.

Here's to authors speaking the truth about cancer with realism and honesty. And 
here's to those on the journey themselves. "There's hope. Look." Loose Threads


emma d dryden said...

Yes! Absolutely true and right.

holly cupala said...

Right on, Lorie Ann! I just recommended Loose Threads on the ABC listserv to a bookseller looking for a book for three pre-teens and teens with a mother in that same situation. I loved that book. It didn't suck!

bookkm said...

If I was a teen with cancer, I would probably think that cancer books suck. But when I was a teen, (cancer came much, much later) I thought those books were fascinating And teens still do.
As teens evolve from children to adults, they can't experience everything. That's where good books on disparate subjects are so, so helpful. Thanks, Lorie, for tackling this painful subject. And, of course, thanks go out to John Green who probably walks on water to relax.

Melissa Walker said...

What Emma said. xoxo

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.